Seedlings in trays being watered indoors with gardening mistake icons, Miss Flowery garden tips

Top 7 Mistakes When Starting Seeds Indoors (and How to Fix Them)

Confused by seed packets or frustrated by leggy seedlings? Starting seeds indoors is a great way to get a head start on the season — but common mistakes like overwatering or poor light can stop your seedlings before they even begin. This guide walks you through the top 7 mistakes and gives clear, actionable seed starting tips so your seedlings grow strong and ready for transplant.

Quick overview — the top 7 mistakes

  • Overwatering (most common)
  • Poor lighting → leggy seedlings
  • Planting seeds at the wrong depth
  • Ignoring soil temperature
  • Crowding seedlings
  • Using the wrong soil or containers
  • Neglecting air circulation & hygiene (damping-off risk)

1. Overwatering: The #1 killer of young seedlings

More water ≠ more growth. Seedling roots need oxygen — soggy soil suffocates them and invites root rot and fungal disease.

Seed Starting Tip: Water only when the top ¼ inch of soil feels dry. Use a spray bottle or narrow-spout can to wet the soil (not the leaves). Use trays with drainage and add perlite to your mix to improve drainage.

2. Skimping on light: Why leggy seedlings happen

Insufficient light makes seedlings stretch toward the nearest light source. They become tall, weak, and more likely to break after transplanting.

Seed Starting Tip: Use a full-spectrum LED grow light 2–4 inches above seedlings for 14–16 hours/day. Use a timer for consistency and raise the light as plants grow. If using a windowsill, rotate trays daily for even growth.

3. Planting seeds too deep (or too shallow)

Seed depth affects germination success: too deep exhausts the seed’s energy; too shallow risks drying or exposure.

Seed Starting Tip: Follow the packet instructions or the rule of thumb: plant seeds at a depth about twice their width. Tiny seeds often just need to be pressed onto the soil surface — cover lightly with vermiculite if needed.

4. Ignoring soil temperature (germination’s secret trigger)

Soil temperature strongly influences germination speed. Example: tomatoes prefer 70–85°F (21–29°C); lettuce prefers cooler soil ~60–70°F (15–21°C).

Seed Starting Tip: Use a soil thermometer and, when necessary, a seedling heat mat to maintain optimal germination temps. Remove the heat mat after seeds sprout and aim for daytime temps ~65–70°F, nighttime ~55–60°F.

5. Crowding seedlings: Give them room to breathe

Planting too many seeds per cell creates competition and high humidity — perfect for damping-off and other fungal problems.

Seed Starting Tip: Plant 2–3 seeds per cell for insurance, then thin to the strongest seedling after the first set of true leaves. Snip extras at the soil line with scissors to avoid disturbing roots.

6. Wrong soil or containers

Garden soil is too heavy and may carry pests; cheap mixes can compact and hold too much moisture.

Seed Starting Tip: Use a sterile, well-draining seed-starting mix formulated for seeds. Start in small cells or peat pots with drainage holes. Avoid reusing old potting soil unless sterilized.

7. Poor air circulation & hygiene

Stagnant, humid conditions encourage damping-off and other fungal diseases that kill seedlings at the soil line.

Seed Starting Tip: Provide gentle airflow (a small fan on low) and avoid overhead watering of foliage. Keep tools and trays clean and discard any soggy or diseased seedlings immediately.

Quick troubleshooting checklist

  • Problem: Leggy seedlings
    Fix: Add light, lower the light distance, increase daily light hours.
  • Problem: Yellow, wilting leaves
    Fix: Check drainage & avoid overwatering.
  • Problem: Slow germination
    Fix: Check soil temp; use heat mat for warm-soil crops.

Seed starting essentials checklist

  • Sterile seed starting mix

  • Seed trays/pots with drainage
  • Full-spectrum LED grow light + timer
  • Soil thermometer & (optional) heat mat
  • Spray bottle / narrow-spout watering can
  • Small fan for air circulation
Back to blog